Main reservoir pipe not present?
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
Main reservoir pipe not present?
Main reservoirs throughout the consist have always been independent in Openbve, as if there's no MR pipe, however, recently it got me thinking, I did some research and realized there are practically no common brake systems that omit MR pipe like this, including those represented in the sim. I think it's something overlooked when transitioning to simulating actual separate cars compared to BVE4 with its "MR pressure on car 0 falls below set value => play compressor sounds, increase MR pressure" logic.
Honestly, I think brakes need more flexibility to become more customizable, but this is a topic for later
Honestly, I think brakes need more flexibility to become more customizable, but this is a topic for later
Delsin- Posts : 313
Join date : 2016-08-20
Re: Main reservoir pipe not present?
It's somewhat worse than that actually
https://github.com/leezer3/OpenBVE/blob/master/source/OpenBVE/Simulation/TrainManager/Train/BrakeSystem.cs#L25
The current code actually has no real brake pipe distribution at all & just uses dummy (averaged) values.
I don't want to know quite what assumptions the physics make either.
https://github.com/leezer3/OpenBVE/blob/master/source/OpenBVE/Simulation/TrainManager/Train/BrakeSystem.cs#L25
The current code actually has no real brake pipe distribution at all & just uses dummy (averaged) values.
I don't want to know quite what assumptions the physics make either.
Re: Main reservoir pipe not present?
Yet it feels realistic and seems to work fine
Until I realised I've never seen compressors going off independently within a train irl, and then turns out it shouldn't work like this at all. For example, on ER2 (something I'm building and that'll probably be completed and released sometime soon) every car has a main reservoir, but only trailers have compressors that pressurize the MR pipe and then the reservoirs, and all compressors are controlled by a single pressure relay in leading cab. It's configured to use simple automatic air brake and even with all that imperfect air brake implementation it seems to behave realistically, though brake pipe discharge rate makes it feel like an EP brake (which exists on ER2, but similarly to BR Mk1 EMUs can be turned on/off) while EPB of this type isn't a thing in BVE yet
Until I realised I've never seen compressors going off independently within a train irl, and then turns out it shouldn't work like this at all. For example, on ER2 (something I'm building and that'll probably be completed and released sometime soon) every car has a main reservoir, but only trailers have compressors that pressurize the MR pipe and then the reservoirs, and all compressors are controlled by a single pressure relay in leading cab. It's configured to use simple automatic air brake and even with all that imperfect air brake implementation it seems to behave realistically, though brake pipe discharge rate makes it feel like an EP brake (which exists on ER2, but similarly to BR Mk1 EMUs can be turned on/off) while EPB of this type isn't a thing in BVE yet
Delsin- Posts : 313
Join date : 2016-08-20
Re: Main reservoir pipe not present?
Your configuration has one inconvenient. OpenBVE doesn't allow you to have electric brake together with automatic air brake, and you will not hear any motor sound while braking. This often prevents me from using this (more realistic) type of air brake.
jorgecerezo- Posts : 55
Join date : 2013-06-26
Similar topics
» Brake pipe not vented completely in emergency braking
» Given key not present in dictionary
» Midland Main Line
» Midland Main Line
» [Steam Deck] Routes missing in the main loader and encoding issues (OpenBVE 1.9.1.1)
» Given key not present in dictionary
» Midland Main Line
» Midland Main Line
» [Steam Deck] Routes missing in the main loader and encoding issues (OpenBVE 1.9.1.1)
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum